City Hall Watcher
City Hall Watcher

City Council — May 2014

ARCHIVED

City Council — May 2014

May 6–8, 2014

43 posts

Council discussing the Eglinton Connects plan, which includes bike lanes. Here's a nice letter sent in support: http://t.co/HCpLrYHUZc

Council votes 38-0 in favour of the Eglinton Connects EA Study. Hey, didn't John Tory want to cancel this thing?

Doug Ford demands media leave his brother alone. If only there was some way for Rob Ford to stop being a public figure with a public salary.

Cheat Sheet. Randy Ford wears a cowboy hat. Doug Ford has a bit more hair. Rob Ford looks like international celebrity Rob Ford.

Council votes 27-14 in favour of retaining a right-turn prohibition at Bracken & Victoria Park. http://t.co/hSSSkcy5z1

Council votes 29-14 to debate ban on EDM events at Exhibition Place. http://t.co/uPIWNEs3mw

Council voteMay 7, 2014, 03:10 p.m.Two-thirds requiredMM51.5

Electronic Dance Music Concerts - Exhibition Place - by Councillor Mike Layton, seconded by Councillor Michael Thompson

Waive referral

two-thirds (29)
29
14
YesNoAbsentMotion carried
Voted yes (29)
AugimeriBailãoBerardinettiCarrollChoColleDavisDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisKellyLaytonLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMcConnellMcMahonMihevcMilczynPalacioPerksPerruzzaStintzVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (14)
AinslieCrawfordCrisantiD. FordGrimesMammolitiMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataParkerPasternakRobinsonShinerThompson
Absent:Di GiorgioR. Ford

Council votes 36-5 in favour of motion that'll ensure Ford doesn't sign any more decommissioned street signs. http://t.co/QYXVPjqxj1

Ford is gone and anyway has few powers. Can't council go back to doing voice votes for some procedural things?

This plan to install digital advertising at TTC shelters doesn't seem to include any requirement that digital screens include nextbus info.

(Not that I'd think it was a good idea even then. But still!)

De Baeremaker suggests that digital bus shelter ads are okay because everyone has a smartphone these days.

Here's how much money Toronto is guaranteed to get through the street furniture/advertising agreement with Astral. http://t.co/7IjBMTHYVn

Street furniture deal is a strong counter-argument to those who like to portray Miller as some unhinged socialist.

(See also: Regent Park project with Daniels, Build Toronto, Invest Toronto, CUPE Sick Bank, Commercial Tax Plan, and so on.)

Here's a chart showing how far behind Astral is at installing the street furniture they were supposed to install. http://t.co/F6brATWZzb

Janet Davis motion to not proceed with changes to street furniture/advertising agreement fails 11-29. http://t.co/TxCTaf038J

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:21 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

Davis - motion 3b

majority (21)
11
29
YesNoAbsentMotion lost
Voted yes (11)
AugimeriDavisDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisMcConnellMihevcPerksVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (29)
AinslieBailãoBerardinettiChoColleCrawfordCrisantiDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeD. FordGrimesKellyLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMcMahonMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakPerruzzaRobinsonShinerStintzThompson
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

McConnell motion to ensure electronic signs don't get installed in heritage neighbourhoods fails 15-25. http://t.co/YKklhNgVyi

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:23 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

McConnell - motion 6a

majority (21)
15
25
YesNoAbsentMotion lost
Voted yes (15)
AugimeriChoDavisDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisMcConnellMcMahonMihevcPerksPerruzzaRobinsonVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (25)
AinslieBailãoBerardinettiColleCrawfordCrisantiDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeD. FordGrimesKellyLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakShinerStintzThompson
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

McConnell motion to involve BIA and councillors in digital signage decisions also fails 15-25.

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:24 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

McConnell - motion 6b

majority (21)
15
25
YesNoAbsentMotion lost
Voted yes (15)
AugimeriDavisDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisGrimesMcConnellMihevcMoeserPerksPerruzzaRobinsonVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (25)
AinslieBailãoBerardinettiChoColleCrawfordCrisantiDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeD. FordKellyLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMcMahonMilczynMinnan-WongNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakShinerStintzThompson
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

At least they're giving me potential votes for the council scorecard.

Perks motion to not allow auditory/interactive ads fails 12-28. http://t.co/RikU5GUHtu

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:25 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

Perks - motion 7a

majority (21)
12
28
YesNoAbsentMotion lost
Voted yes (12)
AugimeriDavisDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisMcConnellMihevcPerksRobinsonVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (28)
AinslieBailãoBerardinettiChoColleCrawfordCrisantiDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeD. FordGrimesKellyLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMcMahonMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakPerruzzaShinerStintzThompson
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

Secondary Perks motion to limit auditory ads to a certain decibal level does carry, 22-18. http://t.co/m8uk7KRAMf

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:26 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

Perks - motion 7b

majority (21)
22
18
YesNoAbsentMotion carried
Voted yes (22)
AugimeriBailãoColleDavisDe BaeremaekerDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisKellyLeonMatlowMcConnellMcMahonMihevcMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserPerksRobinsonVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (18)
AinslieBerardinettiChoCrawfordCrisantiDel GrandeD. FordGrimesLeeLindsay LubyNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakPerruzzaShinerStintzThompson
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

Vaughan motion to only allow illuminated ads in wards where councillors voted in favour of such ads fails 12-28. http://t.co/1ZNblUXhf7

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:26 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

Vaughan - motion 8a

majority (21)
12
28
YesNoAbsentMotion lost
Voted yes (12)
AugimeriDavisDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisMcConnellMihevcPerksRobinsonVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (28)
AinslieBailãoBerardinettiChoColleCrawfordCrisantiDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeD. FordGrimesKellyLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMcMahonMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakPerruzzaShinerStintzThompson
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

Vaughan motion to review shelter ad design to ensure public safety and security passes 27-13. http://t.co/sx7kocK1Ks

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:28 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

Vaughan - motion 8c

majority (21)
27
13
YesNoAbsentMotion carried
Voted yes (27)
AinslieAugimeriBailãoChoCrisantiDavisDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisLeeMatlowMcConnellMcMahonMihevcMilczynMoeserPalacioPasternakPerksPerruzzaRobinsonShinerStintzThompsonVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (13)
BerardinettiColleCrawfordDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeD. FordGrimesKellyLeonLindsay LubyMinnan-WongNunziataParker
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

New street advertising agreement passes 29-11. Get ready for talking bus shelters. http://t.co/lTF7v8TRNg

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 11:34 a.m.CC51.8

Toronto Street Furniture Program - Agreement Modifications

Adopt the item as amended

majority (21)
29
11
YesNoAbsentMotion carried
Voted yes (29)
AinslieBailãoBerardinettiChoColleCrawfordCrisantiDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeD. FordGrimesKellyLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMcMahonMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakPerruzzaRobinsonShinerStintzThompson
Voted no (11)
AugimeriDavisDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisMcConnellMihevcPerksVaughanWong-Tam
Absent:CarrollDi GiorgioR. FordLaytonMammoliti

Back at council, Denzil Minnan-Wong is joking about creating a "Twitter laureate." I can think of a few nominees.

As Council considers a Photo Laureate position, let's read about Arthur Goss, TO's first official photographer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Goss

Norm Kelly says "world class city." Drink up.

Minnan-Wong motion to require that any photo laureate position be funded with sponsorship FAILS 17-19. http://t.co/HLchQ5qvSU

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 02:26 p.m.MM51.1

Creating a "Photo Laureate" for Toronto - by Councillor Joe Mihevc, seconded by Councillor Paul Ainslie

Minnan-Wong - motion 2

majority (19)
17
19
YesNoAbsentMotion lost
Voted yes (17)
BerardinettiCrawfordDel GrandeGrimesLeeLeonMatlowMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakPerruzzaRobinsonShiner
Voted no (19)
AinslieAugimeriBailãoCarrollDavisDe BaeremaekerDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisKellyLaytonLindsay LubyMcConnellMcMahonMihevcPerksThompsonWong-Tam
Absent:ChoColleCrisantiDi GiorgioD. FordR. FordMammolitiStintzVaughan

But a Mihevc motion to SEEK sponsorship for the Photo Laureate position PASSES 35-2.

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 02:27 p.m.MM51.1

Creating a "Photo Laureate" for Toronto - by Councillor Joe Mihevc, seconded by Councillor Paul Ainslie

Mihevc - motion 1

majority (19)
35
2
YesNoAbsentMotion carried
Voted yes (35)
AinslieAugimeriBailãoBerardinettiCarrollColleCrawfordDavisDe BaeremaekerDel GrandeDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisGrimesKellyLaytonLeeLeonLindsay LubyMatlowMcConnellMcMahonMihevcMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakRobinsonShinerThompsonWong-Tam
Voted no (2)
PerksPerruzza
Absent:ChoCrisantiDi GiorgioD. FordR. FordMammolitiStintzVaughan

Matlow motion there be no cash for the Photo Laureate and that all their pics go to the Archives PASSES 22-15. Uh. http://t.co/KuhvlWr23v

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 02:28 p.m.MM51.1

Creating a "Photo Laureate" for Toronto - by Councillor Joe Mihevc, seconded by Councillor Paul Ainslie

Matlow - motion 3

majority (19)
22
15
YesNoAbsentMotion carried
Voted yes (22)
AugimeriBerardinettiCrawfordDavisDel GrandeGrimesKellyMatlowMcConnellMcMahonMilczynMinnan-WongMoeserNunziataPalacioParkerPasternakPerruzzaRobinsonShinerThompsonWong-Tam
Voted no (15)
AinslieBailãoCarrollColleDe BaeremaekerDoucetteFilionFletcherFragedakisLaytonLeeLeonLindsay LubyMihevcPerks
Absent:ChoCrisantiDi GiorgioD. FordR. FordMammolitiStintzVaughan

I don't know how I feel about the city effectively not paying an artist for their work while retaining copyright.

But anyway. After a vote of 30-7, the city will now maybe have an unpaid Photo Laureate. Hooray? http://t.co/xC81nBGzwD

It's funny how some councillors are all "think of the children" until you start talking about, say, lowering speed limits.

Too bad council didn't go in camera to discuss the photo laureate. We would have come up with some great jokes.

And council goes in camera yet again. Remember when Ford pledged to make minutes from in camera meetings public after a certain time period?

Councillor Perruzza now listing things he does not understand. It's a long list.

Council votes 8-26 against deferring the item relating to EDM ban. They'll make a decision today. http://t.co/5RoWJRC3V7

Council votes 27-6 to take an immediate vote on the EDM ban. This is our third act of Footloose moment.

Council voteMay 8, 2014, 04:53 p.m.Two-thirds requiredMM51.5

Electronic Dance Music Concerts - Exhibition Place - by Councillor Mike Layton, seconded by Councillor Michael Thompson

End debate

two-thirds (23)
27
6
YesNoAbsentMotion carried
Voted yes (27)
AinslieAugimeriBailãoBerardinettiCarrollChoCrawfordDavisDel GrandeDoucetteFilionFragedakisKellyLaytonLeeLeonLindsay LubyMcConnellMcMahonMihevcMinnan-WongParkerPasternakPerksThompsonVaughanWong-Tam
Voted no (6)
ColleDe BaeremaekerGrimesMatlowPerruzzaRobinson
Absent:CrisantiDi GiorgioFletcherD. FordR. FordMammolitiMilczynMoeserNunziataPalacioShinerStintz

And council votes to overrule the Exhibition Place board and keep EDM events, 31-4. http://t.co/ns5NWWvdxv

Perruzza now showing classroom-made video of teacher disposing of coffee cup and children getting angry.

The precocious children in this video have now come up with a solution for recyclable coffee cups using math and science.

That was an A+ video. I am convinced. Let's have recyclable coffee cups.

Doug Ford is only councillor to vote against moving forward with recyclable hot drink cups.

City Council — May 2014 — CHW Live